Hero Background

Fair Share Spending, 2026

Making hospital tax breaks work for communities.

What is Fair Share Spending?

(methodology | press release)

Hospitals are vital community partners, providing lifesaving emergency care and essential preventive services. They are also big businesses, accounting for one-third of the total healthcare spending in the U.S. 

Nonprofit hospitals are expected to give back to their communities in return for being tax-exempt. That spending can sometimes mean the difference between patients going into medical debt or not, communities losing or gaining access to needed services, and local public health initiatives failing or thriving.

We track fair share spending, the difference between the value of a hospitals tax exemption and what it spends on its community, to understand how well hospitals are fulfilling their end of the bargain.

We evaluate fair share spending for 3,037 hospitals, using FYE 2023 data from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) form 990, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) hospital cost reports, and local property assessment portals.

  • KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Over half (52%) of hospitals had a fair share deficit, meaning they did not spend as much on communities as they received in as tax exemption value.
  • Fair share deficit hospitals received $27.5 billion in tax exemptions and gave back $12 billion, resulting in a net deficit to communities of $15.5 billion.
  • Fair share surplus hospitals received $11.3 billion in tax exemptions and gave back $25.1 billion, resulting in a net benefit to communities of $13.8 billion.
  • California, Florida, Illinois, and Ohio each had a statewide fair share deficit exceeding $1 billion.
  • Nonprofit hospitals hold $240 billion worth of real estate, an amount that exceeds the assessed value of all taxable property in Colorado.

Fair Share Spending by Hospital

Largest Fair Share Deficits

Among the 3,037 hospitals included in the analysis, 52% received more in tax exemptions than they spent on community investment (including financial assistance, subsidized health services, and direct spending on community health programs). The gap in spending for these hospitals amounted to about $16 billion. That’s enough to relieve medical debt for 12 million Americans.

Hospital Tax exemption value Community Investment Fair Share Spending
Mayo Clinic Hospital
(Rochester, MN)
$433M $67M $-366M
Tisch Hospital
(New York, NY)
$522M $228M $-294M
Stanford Hospital
(Stanford, CA)
$283M $28M $-255M
New York-Presbyterian Hospital
(New York, NY)
$656M $407M $-248M
Massachusetts General Hospital
(Boston, MA)
$350M $130M $-219M
IU Health Methodist Hospital
(Indianapolis, IN)
$323M $107M $-216M
Orlando Regional Medical Center
(Orlando, FL)
$318M $110M $-208M
Nationwide Children’s Hospital
(Columbus, OH)
$254M $63M $-191M
Inova Fairfax Hospital
(Falls Church, VA)
$224M $83M $-141M
Cleveland Clinic
(Cleveland, OH)
$238M $98M $-140M

Largest Fair Share Surpluses

Fair share surplus hospitals received $11.3 billion in tax exemptions and gave back $25.1 billion to communities, resulting in a net benefit to communities of $13.8 billion.

The following hospitals had the largest fair share surpluses in 2023.

Hospital Tax exemption value Community Investment Fair Share Spending
North Shore University Hospital
(Manhasset, NY)
$65M $232M $167M
Rochester General Hospital
(Rochester, NY)
$37M $183M $146M
Englewood Hospital
(Englewood, NJ)
$14M $157M $142M
One Brooklyn Health
(Brooklyn, NY)
$22M $158M $136M
Hackensack University Medical Center
(Hackensack, NJ)
$81M $205M $124M
Sanford USD Medical Center
(Sioux Falls, SD)
$55M $158M $103M
New York-Presbyterian Queens
(Flushing, NY)
$19M $120M $102M
Strong Memorial Hospital
(Rochester, NY)
$70M $171M $101M
St. Joseph’s University Medical Center
(Paterson, NJ)
$29M $129M $100M
Barnes-Jewish Hospital
(Saint Louis, MO)
$73M $168M $95M

What are high-surplus hospitals spending on?

For most of these hospitals, the largest category of community investment was subsidized health services. The IRS defines subsidized health services as clinical services provided despite a financial loss to the organization that meet an identified community need. Examples of these services from hospitals in this study include mental health, NICU services, dental services, medical care and social services for refugee children, primary care, substance use services, home health care, cancer, and obstetrics-gynecology.

Despite reporting tens of millions of dollars (sometimes hundreds of millions) in spending on this category, few hospitals provide more information on Schedule H on exactly which services are included. Of 50 hospitals reporting at least $50 million in subsidized healthcare services in 2023, only 9 hospitals listed any specific services included in this category beyond “physician clinics.”

State Fair Share Deficits

Fair share spending varied widely by state, ranging from in -$2 million in Mississippi to in -$1.7 billion in California. Four states (CA, FL, IL, OH) had fair share deficits greater than $1 billion. The proportion of hospitals with fair share deficits by state ranged from 8% in Maryland to 81% in Ohio.

State Number of Hospitals Percent of hospitals with deficit Total fair share deficit How many medical debts could be relieved?
Alabama 32 38% -$20 M 39,867
Alaska 8 38% -$39 M 7,809
Arizona 53 47% -$380 M 341,236
Arkansas 57 51% -$84 M 155,375
California 209 48% -$1,679 M 795,137
Colorado 46 74% -$220 M 193,573
Connecticut 29 55% -$117 M 128,557
Delaware 7 29% -$44 M 83,863
Florida 100 57% -$1,089 M 771,408
Georgia 90 37% -$319 M 377,680
Hawaii 16 50% -$32 M 6,389
Idaho 19 21% -$16 M 31,400
Illinois 152 64% -$1,259 M 468,321
Indiana 80 60% -$752 M 335,721
Iowa 53 68% -$132 M 88,986
Kansas 54 57% -$53 M 66,931
Kentucky 77 61% -$240 M 221,751
Louisiana 47 49% -$267 M 146,047
Maine 32 41% -$38 M 29,980
Maryland 48 8% -$67 M 121,173
Massachusetts 54 54% -$563 M 277,501
Michigan 112 78% -$401 M 396,891
Minnesota 107 54% -$591 M 337,092
Mississippi 34 9% -$2 M 3,824
Missouri 64 62% -$355 M 299,757
Montana 53 23% -$4 M 7,421
Nebraska 52 69% -$228 M 74,584
Nevada 11 55% -$29 M 58,540
New Hampshire 23 39% -$56 M 17,780
New Jersey 57 23% -$308 M 323,107
New Mexico 15 47% -$18 M 36,898
New York 133 44% -$960 M 641,995
North Carolina 63 43% -$109 M 218,173
North Dakota 42 50% -$33 M 6,692
Ohio 141 81% -$1,349 M 738,729
Oklahoma 39 33% -$57 M 88,203
Oregon 42 45% -$110 M 130,923
Pennsylvania 145 62% -$905 M 594,269
Rhode Island 9 33% -$22 M 12,839
South Carolina 29 45% -$101 M 202,969
South Dakota 47 21% -$8 M 8,301
Tennessee 51 16% -$18 M 36,191
Texas 171 45% -$770 M 801,519
Utah 28 61% -$101 M 68,453
Vermont 15 27% -$3 M 6,930
Virginia 66 53% -$591 M 337,596
Washington 48 29% -$160 M 213,045
Washington, DC 6 50% -$60 M 35,281
West Virginia 40 68% -$136 M 90,380
Wisconsin 125 70% -$633 M 341,815
Wyoming 7 14% -$6 M 7,173

Hospital Tax Exemption Breakdown

In 2023, nonprofit hospitals collectively received $38.8 billion in federal, state, and local tax benefits, an average of $12.8 million per hospital or 3.8% of total expenses.

The largest proportion of the tax exemption value was federal income tax at $12.2 billion, followed by sales at $7.9 billion and property taxes at $7.8 billion. State income tax, the value of tax-exempt bonds and donations, and federal unemployment tax collectively accounted for $11 billion. Not included in this total are other benefits that tax-exempt hospitals may receive, such as Medicaid disproportionate share payments ($16 billion in 2023), 340B discounts (totaling $66 B in 2023), and profits from indirect tax arbitrage (estimated at $7 B in 2022).

Hospital tax exemption value was very unevenly distributed. The top 1% of hospitals by tax exemption value (30 hospitals) had a collective tax exemption of $6.8 billion, about 18% of the total. The top 20% of hospitals by tax exemption (607 hospitals) account for 75% of the total tax exemption value for all hospitals.

Policy Recommendations

The case for fixing—not eliminating—the tax exemption

Our Fair Share findings show that about half of nonprofit hospitals provide as much in financial assistance and other community investments as they receive in tax exemption value, and many hospitals are going above and beyond in their provision of community investment. For these hospitals, the nonprofit tax exemption, along with other benefits such as 340B and disproportionate share payments, may be an important tool for financial stability.

Nonprofit status has other benefits for communities. The requirement to file a 990 increases transparency relative to for-profit hospitals, and provides a policy lever by which community members can hold hospitals accountable. Removing nonprofit status would take away that lever and put communities in the dark.

However, we clearly need action to bring all hospitals up to the level of those at the top. Here are recommendations for how policymakers can improve transparency and accountability around nonprofit hospital community benefits:

Fixing transparency in reporting

IRS Form 990 is a valuable source of information on nonprofit hospital community benefit spending, yet this form is often missing crucial details to understand how well hospitals are serving community needs. To close these loopholes, policymakers can:

  1. Require hospitals to include the top 3-5 community health needs identified in their Community Health Needs Assessment, the programs taken to address these needs, and the amount of spending on each program.
  2. Require hospitals to name the specific services included within the category of subsidized health services. In our analysis, hospitals reported $14.6 B in spending on subsidized health services collectively—the second-largest category of community investment spending—but few include information on which specific services are being subsidized in this reporting.
  3. Require hospitals to include the number of financial assistance applications received, approved, and denied, as well as the number of extraordinary collection actions (such as lawsuits) taken against patients to collect medical debt. Nonprofit hospitals are allowed to conduct these actions, but there is very little transparency around which hospitals conduct them and how frequently.
  4. Address low-hanging fruit such as including hospital CMS provider number on the Form 990 for easier mapping across data sets and require community benefit spending to be broken out by facility.

The “Tax Exempt Hospital Transparency Act” (H.R. 9504) proposes several of the requirements listed above. The bill also modifies requirements based on hospital type and revenue, so that smaller and rural hospitals are not burdened with as many additional reporting requirements.

Fixing underspending on communities

The IRS does not require hospitals to spend a certain amount on financial assistance or community benefits. As a result, about half of nonprofit hospitals, including many of the largest hospitals in the U.S., spent less on community investment than they received in tax breaks in 2023, leaving a collective $16 billion spending gap. Our research shows that community investment spending ranged from $6,000/bed for the lowest-spending 10% of hospitals to $171,000/bed in 2023. Nearly 50 hospitals reported $0 in spending on financial assistance or community health.

To increase spending on communities, policymakers can:

  1. Make financial assistance easier to access through patient screening requirements, standardized eligibility thresholds, uniform applications, and removal of restrictions on FA such as asset tests.
  2. Set spending targets for hospitals based on their tax exemption value, or some combination of hospital size, financial health, and previous spending. Ideally, the spending target would apply to programs the hospitals is undertaking to address priority health needs identified in their Community Health Needs Assessment. Spending could also include contributions to a local or state funding pool that could be redistributed, if hospitals do not feel equipped to conduct their own programs around a specific health need. Hospitals could be required to include this target on their 990, along with their actual spending on the top 3-5 community health needs from the previous year.

Protecting in the short term, restructuring in the long term

H.R.1, the budget reconciliation bill passed in 2025, introduces Medicaid work requirements, restricts use of state-directed payments and provider taxes, and reduces ACA enrollment periods. These provisions, plus the loss of ACA expanded premium subsidies in 2026, are estimated to reduce hospital revenue by more than $500 Billion over the next decade. Hundreds of rural hospitals have been deemed at risk of closure from HR1 due to high Medicaid payer mix and thin margins.

The Lown Institute’s data on fair share spending provides insight on which hospitals are less privileged based on their income and tax exemption value, and which of these hospitals are already giving back more than expected in financial assistance and community health. These factors may indicate areas where more assistance is needed.

Policymakers should do the following to protect hospitals in the short term:

  • Increase Medicare payment rates for hospitals with high proportions of low-income Medicare patients and uncompensated care, as recommended by the independent Medicare Payment Advisory Council.
  • Provide additional funding for rural hospitals in demonstrated consistent financial distress.

In the long term, the way that we pay hospitals needs to be transformed. The current system is unsustainable for many hospitals, encourages more services over keeping people healthy, values privately-insured patients above those with public insurance and high-margin elective procedures above preventive care. Our market-based system also rewards hospitals for being bigger and more consolidated with higher prices, resulting in greater costs for everyone.

Policymakers should consider the following systemic reforms to align incentives for hospitals and communities:

  • Support total cost of care models like AHEAD that equalize reimbursement rates across payers and set global budgets. We cannot expect hospitals to care for all patients equally when they’re paid more for privately-insured patients.
  • Increase reimbursement for underfunded high-need services, such as behavioral healthcare, substance use treatment, and primary care. Policymakers have proposed doing this using savings from site-neutral payments. 
  • Reduce excessive prices. High health care costs—driven in part by hospital consolidation and price increases—can erode communities’ financial health. Policymakers should look to reduce cost through site-neutral payments, payment caps, reference pricing, or limits on charges for low-income patients.
  • Checks on consolidation. Hospital systems are becoming increasingly large and consolidated, resulting in higher prices. States should use their regulatory authority to review mergers and acquisition that would substantially reduce competition and potentially. States could add conditions to these deals that require additional community investment or medical debt relief.

Methodology

This analysis builds on previous research to calculate fair share spending—the difference between hospitals’ meaningful community investment and the value of their tax exemptions. 

Community investment

Nonprofit hospital community benefit spending is reported on IRS Form 990 Schedule H. We use IRS data for fiscal year ending 2023. We linked Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) cost reports to IRS tax filings through an address-mapping algorithm.

Community investment categories

We include the following IRS categories of community benefit most likely to have a direct and meaningful impact on community health, which we refer to as meaningful community investment: 

  • Financial assistance – Free and discounted care provided to patients eligible for financial assistance under the hospital’s policy. Reported as the cost to the hospital (not charges). Bad debt is not included.
  • Subsidized health services – Clinical services that meet an identified community need and are provided despite a loss to the hospital. Examples include primary care clinics, addiction treatment, and neonatal care.
  • Community health improvement services – Programs provided by the hospital for the purpose of improving health. Examples include health fairs, free immunizations, and interpreter services. Includes the operating costs of community benefit programs.
  • Cash and in-kind contributions – Contributions made to other nonprofits to improve health. Contributions to affiliated medical schools or physician groups and other hospitals in this study were excluded. 
  • Community building activities – Programs that address the social drivers of health, such as housing, community advocacy, and environmental initiatives, as reported on Schedule H Part II. Although this category is not always considered a community benefit, we include it because addressing the social drivers of health is critical for improving long-term community health. 

Excluded categories of community benefit

Medicaid shortfall is the gap between hospitals’ costs for serving Medicaid beneficiaries and payments received for these patients. While Medicaid shortfall represents nearly half of reported community benefit spending, researchers have expressed concerns about including it as a community benefit:

  1. Hospital losses on Medicaid patients is not funding that goes into the community to improve health. It is an accounting measure, not direct spending.  
  2. Hospitals with costs of care far higher than Medicaid payment rates will have a greater shortfall, regardless of the number of Medicaid patients served. 
  3. States set their Medicaid rates at a level believed to be sufficient to cover hospital costs. If the IRS does not consider discounts for other insurers to be community benefits, it’s unclear why Medicaid should be different.
  4. Most hospitals already make up for Medicaid shortfalls by charging private insurers above the cost of care and receiving other benefits such as 340b payments.

Health professions education and research were not included because it is not clear that these investments have a direct impact on community health. Only about one-quarter of resident physicians report practicing in underserved areas after their training and only 35% go on to practice primary care. Additionally, hospitals are already reimbursed for trainees through medical education payments they receive from Medicare, not all of which are reported on Form 990. While research funding is a public good, it is unlikely that a hospital’s research has a direct impact on community health.

Prorating process

Many hospitals file a combined Form 990 with other hospitals in a system. For these systems, community investment was prorated among hospitals based on their share of system financial assistance in cost reports. Bonds and donations were prorated based on hospitals’ share of system revenue.  

Tax exemption value

Our calculation of hospital tax exemption value draws from six previous analyses and includes the following categories: 

  • Federal corporate income tax – Federal corporate income tax rate (21%) applied to net income from hospital cost reports, adjusted for prior year losses and other taxes paid
  • State corporate income tax – State-specific corporate tax rate applied to net income from hospital cost reports, adjusted for prior year losses and other taxes paid
  • State & local sales tax – State and local tax rates applied to supply expenses from American Hospitals Association survey
  • Property tax – Local property tax rates applied to real property values from local assessment portals and value of equipment from cost reports 
  • Tax-exempt bonds – Difference between corporate and nonprofit bond interest rates, applied to outstanding bond liabilities from Form 990
  • Tax-exempt charitable donations – Value of tax-exempt donations from Form 990, excluding government grants and in-kind donations
  • Federal unemployment tax exemption – Federal unemployment tax rate applied to the first $7,000 of full time employee total

Limitations

Hospital data set. We include all hospitals with both IRS Form 990 and CMS cost report data available from 2023. We removed hospitals that closed, converted to for-profit, or were removed from Care Compare as of May 2026; however, there may be updates since then for which we have not accounted. We do not include certain hospitals that are publicly-owned and do not file a 990, nor do we include certain children’s or cancer hospitals without cost report data, which may underestimate the fair share deficit.

Data availability and accuracy. Our results are limited by the availability and accuracy of the data used. Hospitals may undertake impactful community development activities that are not reported on the 990, such as local hiring and sourcing. Hospitals are not required to have cost reports audited by independent accounting firms; therefore, there may be inaccuracies in the income reported. Property values in certain states were unavailable and had to be imputed.

Study assumptions. Similar to previous studies, we assume that hospitals’ reported income would not significantly change if they were for-profit. While hospitals would want to decrease their tax liability, they would also be under pressure from shareholders to make a profit. Our prorating method assumes that hospitals in group filings that spend more on financial assistance also spend more on other categories of community investment, although this may not always be the case.

Media inquiries should be directed to Aaron Toleos, vice president of communications for the Lown Institute, at atoleos@lowninstitute.org.

For commercial and academic data requests, use the data request form.